Coronavirus
Coronavirus Information Center
Severe weather outlook South Dakota

Trump sued for blocking stimulus checks to Americans married to immigrants

National News

President Donald Trump listens during a briefing about the coronavirus in the James Brady Press Briefing Room of the White House, Tuesday, April 21, 2020, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

President Donald Trump faces a lawsuit over the federal government declining to make $1,200 stimulus checks to U.S. citizens who are married to immigrants without Social Security numbers. The litigation comes after the IRS said only married couples who both hold valid Social Security numbers will receive the payments.

The suit, filed by a U.S. citizen and Illinois resident identified only as “John Doe,” alleges that the ban violates the Constitution and is a form of discrimination “based solely on whom he chose to marry.” 

The stimulus checks are part of the government’s $2.2 trillion coronavirus relief package, which provides $1,200 for single taxpayers earning less than $75,000 and $2,400 for married couples earning less than $150,000.

The plaintiff in the suit would have qualified for a $1,200 stimulus check except that he files taxes with his immigrant spouse, who uses an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number, according to the lawsuit, which also names Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin as defendants. The lawsuit also states that his children are excluded because one parent is an immigrant. Under the CARES Act, families with children under the age of 17 will receive $500 per child.

“Had plaintiff not been married to an immigrant, plaintiff and his children would have otherwise qualified for a stimulus check,” the lawsuit claims.

Policy experts have raised concerns that the Corona Aid, Relief, and Economic Security, or CARES, Act bars immigrants, except those with Green Cards that allow them to live and work in the U.S., from receiving the stimulus checks. Many legal immigrants pay taxes and otherwise contribute to the U.S. economy.

Mr. Trump and the other defendants have failed “to treat him as equal to his fellow United States citizens based solely on whom he chose to marry,” the lawsuit alleges. John Doe “has lawfully filed taxes in the United States, yet he is being denied the rights and privileges under the CARES Act.”

The decision to exclude U.S. citizens who are married to immigrants without Social Security numbers affects 1.2 million Americans, according to the Migration Policy Institute. There were 2.3 million foreign nationals on temporary visas in 2016, according to the non-partisan think tank. 

“Presumptively unconstitutional”?

There are two exceptions to the issue that sparked the lawsuit. First, if either spouse is a member of the Armed Forces at any time during the tax year, only one of them is required to have a valid Social Security number, the IRS says. 

Second, taxpayers who are citizens and file separately from their immigrant spouses who lack a Social Security number will receive half of the payment for married couples, or $1,200, according to the IRS. 

That second exception could give some couples a chance to file their taxes separately, given that the 2019 filing deadline has been pushed back to July 15. However, many taxpayers have already filed their returns for 2019. 

Even so, the carve-out that excludes U.S. citizens with immigrant spouses who lack Social Security numbers is harmful and “without serving any legitimate governmental interest,” the lawsuit claims. 

“Discrimination based on the alienage of a U.S. citizen’s spouse is presumptively unconstitutional and subject to strict scrutiny,” it claims. The lawsuit was filed Friday in a federal court in Chicago.

Copyright 2020 Nexstar Broadcasting, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Recent Videos

Summer Reading

Thumbnail for the video titled "Summer Reading"

New Salem Track & Field

Thumbnail for the video titled "New Salem Track & Field"

Class B Baseball

Thumbnail for the video titled "Class B Baseball"

Wednesday, May 27th, 2020 - KX Storm Team Evening Forecast - Dave Holder

Thumbnail for the video titled "Wednesday, May 27th, 2020 - KX Storm Team Evening Forecast - Dave Holder"

Bismarck City Commission

Thumbnail for the video titled "Bismarck City Commission"

Brandi Jude City Commission

Thumbnail for the video titled "Brandi Jude City Commission"

Steve Marquardt City Commission

Thumbnail for the video titled "Steve Marquardt City Commission"

Mike Connelly City Commission

Thumbnail for the video titled "Mike Connelly City Commission"

Mark Splonskowski City Commission

Thumbnail for the video titled "Mark Splonskowski City Commission"

Kids and Anxiety: Expert Panel

Thumbnail for the video titled "Kids and Anxiety: Expert Panel"

KX Storm Team Full Evening Forecast w/Tom Schrader 5/27

Thumbnail for the video titled "KX Storm Team Full Evening Forecast w/Tom Schrader 5/27"

Grand Forks Shooting

Thumbnail for the video titled "Grand Forks Shooting"

Job Market

Thumbnail for the video titled "Job Market"

Amber's Wednesday Morning #OneMinuteForecast 5/27

Thumbnail for the video titled "Amber's Wednesday Morning #OneMinuteForecast 5/27"

Wednesday's Forecast: Mostly sunny, & breezy

Thumbnail for the video titled "Wednesday's Forecast: Mostly sunny, & breezy"

Sunscreen warnings

Thumbnail for the video titled "Sunscreen warnings"

BisMan Lacrosse

Thumbnail for the video titled "BisMan Lacrosse"

Bismarck Governors

Thumbnail for the video titled "Bismarck Governors"

Bismarck Fireworks?

Thumbnail for the video titled "Bismarck Fireworks?"

Camaro Night

Thumbnail for the video titled "Camaro Night"
More Video

COVID Symptoms infographic

KX News Trending Stories

North Dakota Resources

North Dakota Resources

More Resources

Don't Miss

Daily Pledge

More Daily Pledge